He's not a "sexy" player. He never will be. He was never supposed to be.
He wasn't brought on for his offensive capabilities. All of those assets are just icing on the cake. Matt Martin was brought in for one thing only...to instill fear in the hearts of opponents.
They say the role of the enforcer is dead and gone. I say that teams are too enamoured by the advanced stats like Corsi to really be paying attention to what's going on at ice level, and more importantly outside of the rink.
When the Leafs submitted their protected list for the NHL Draft, Matt Martin was a name that was immediately flagged by Leafs fans. There seem to be an equal divide of fans that believe it was the right move and ones that believe it was a mistake. After having a couple of days to digest this and see who the Leafs left exposed, I've pitched my tent in camp "pro Martin".
Stick With What You Know
The Leafs know what they are getting with Martin. Remember that they signed this guy as a free agent last offseason with the knowledge of the Golden Knights and the expansion draft upcoming for the following year. The front office knew that unless Martin was injured all year or had zero effect on the team, they would be keeping him.
Martin was neither of the two.
Let me break it down for you. Since entering the league as a full-time player with the Islander in the 2010-11 season, Martin has been averaging around 14 points and around 120 penalty minutes per season. This past season he put up 9 points and 123 penalty minutes. A five point difference with a 4th line player like Martin is pretty insignificant because of the other intangibles he brings.
He brings a sense of safety for his teammates whenever he is on the ice. And even when he's not, opposing players know that if they go after any of the big three of Matthews, Marner or Nylander, Martin would make sure to track you down on his next shift. He's like a bouncer at a nightclub...whenever one of your boys gets too rowdy, he comes up and gently reminds him and your crew to settle down or he will kick everyone's ass.
The Leafs players love this guy. The Leafs coaching staff love this guy. The Leafs management love this guy. Tell me this picture doesn't speak a thousand words.
If you do a Google search of Matt Martin and look through the images, it's hard to find one that doesn't have him smiling. That type of attitude and positivity is infectious, especially when you basically live with your teammates for about seven months of the year.
Does it suck to lose Brendan Leipsic to Vegas? Absolutely. He was part of the Cody Franson trade to Nashville, and he was the main piece to come back. Even though he's a highly regarded prospect, that's just what he is...a prospect. The Leafs can't field six full lines of forwards every night. There's no room for Leipsic on the team, and I would rather have Martin than Leipsic on my fourth line come next season.
So everybody needs to take a calm and collective deep breath. This Leafs brass is some of the best management minds the league has ever seen in the same room. They understand the team better than anybody else. They know what makes them tick, they know what is important to them, and they know who the "glue" players are; the guys who can keep a locker room together through thick and thin. Martin is a "glue guy".
If you still don't think that Martin is an important piece to the Leafs and their locker room, let me direct you to this article written by Sportsnet's Chris Johnston on Martin and his "big brother" role with the team.
Back yet? Perfect. So hopefully you understand how highly valued this guy is to everyone on the Leafs. I can guarantee you that if the Leafs lost Martin to Vegas, there would be an internal uproar from the players. I'm positive that Leipsic wouldn't have received that kind of support.
I'll be the first to admit that Martin won't ever impress on the score board, but I'm perfectly content with that. I know that the guys like Matthews, Marner, Nylander, Bozak, JVR, Kadri, Brown and more can carry that load offensively. Martin is the "glue guy". He brings a sense of safety on the ice. He protects his young budding superstars. He injects positivity and chemistry into the locker room. He creates a family atmosphere, regardless of age.
This is why every NHL team needs a Matt Martin.